Ivory stucco home with dark-framed glazing and a raised limestone terrace beside a royal palm and green lawn.

Same Tables, New Hands: What's Different on Marco Island as Season Returns

"We like the place as is," Paulo Teixeira told Coastal Breeze News this spring, soon after his partnership took over The SpeakEasy. He listed what would stay the same: the staff, the chef "basically," and the menu, with specials added now and then. The one physical change he hoped for was a patio roof extended toward the water, if permits come through.

That quote sums up the island's restaurant year better than any list of openings. Between March 31 and June 1, three well-known Marco Island spots changed owners, according to Coastal Breeze News stories that ran in its late-May and early-June 2026 editions. In each case the buyer was already part of the place, either as a partner, a longtime regular, or a resident who wanted the dishes left alone. The newest dining room on the island so far is still a site plan on Bald Eagle Drive, and getting it approved took a City Council meeting that ran almost to 1 a.m.

One Owner, Two Exits

Two of the spring sales come from a single decision. Michael Jones bought The SpeakEasy in 2018 with Kent Ward and his brother Mark, through the Jones Restaurant Group. In 2018 he was also principal owner of Marco Island Brewery, which he bought from Frank LaCava. Jones explained the sale plainly: "We owned it eight years and I'm 75 years old, so it's time to relax." Teixeira said Jones "was in the process of selling both of his restaurants on the island."

Both restaurants went to people who already knew them well.

At The SpeakEasy, the 1920s Chicago-themed waterside restaurant in the Chamber of Commerce Plaza, Teixeira is principal owner. His partners are the people who already ran it day to day: Cindy Marotta, Robert "Bobby" Nash and Wade Mundinger. Teixeira and his wife, Priscilla, had been going there since it opened in 2014. He described the restaurant as "a little bit iconic and popular on the island, with locals and tourists alike" and said he wants to keep its local feel.

At the Brewery, C.J. Muntwyler had been Jones's partner. He became sole owner on June 1 by buying out the corporation. He moved to Marco from Chicago at 15 and started bussing tables at the Sandbar about 20 years ago. In 2017 he helped open Mario's on Bald Eagle Drive, which has since closed. His wife, Danielle, now runs the Brewery with him. The couple plan "a host of new menu items" and say they want to be "onsite owners every day, knowing the names of our customers." The Brewery has been in Marco Town Center since 2010, which makes this its third owner.

The Third Handoff, on Park Avenue

The Italian Deli and Market changed hands on its own schedule, but the pattern was the same. Longtime residents Tony Oliverio and Gary Van Cleef bought both the restaurant and its property on March 31 and opened under their ownership on April 1. The sellers were former councilman Jared Grifoni and his father, James. "People absolutely love the food, so I don't want to change any of the recipes or any of the staple dishes," Oliverio said.

Here is what has changed at 902 Park Ave. so far:

  • Drinks come in glasses and entrées on porcelain plates with metal cutlery. Oliverio called the move away from plastic "the most significant change."
  • The wine and liquor lists now include higher-end bottles. His twin brother Joe chose them and runs the restaurant day to day.
  • The deli cases will carry more prepared foods.
  • Live music used to play daily. For now it is limited to Monday karaoke, because guests said the room got too loud to talk. Oliverio says he will decide later which nights music returns.
  • He expects to close for a few days to a week at some point for cleaning, painting, repairs and landscaping. No dates have been set.

Oliverio also addressed rumors that the restaurant would close or turn into something else. "We are operating business as usual," he said.

Place Address Effective New hands What the owners say stays
Italian Deli and Market 902 Park Ave. April 1 Tony Oliverio, Gary Van Cleef; Joe Oliverio runs it daily Recipes and staple dishes
The SpeakEasy 1106 N. Collier Blvd. May 1 Paulo Teixeira with managers Marotta, Nash, Mundinger Staff, chef, menu
Marco Island Brewery 1089 N. Collier Blvd., Unit 427 June 1 C.J. and Danielle Muntwyler Food quality, with new menu items added

Where the Change Went Further

Two other 2026 changes went further than a change of owners, and one place is simply gone.

On Bald Eagle Drive, Zaza Mexican restaurant became a Mediterranean restaurant in early September, according to Tim Aten's October roundup in the Naples Press. Chef Esteban Ortiz's site calls the new restaurant Marazul, at 1095 Bald Eagle Dr., Unit 8, and says Zaza ran through August 2026. The Naples Press spells the name "Mareazul." Even here the change came from inside: the owner changed the cuisine and the business stayed put.

Summer Day Cafe moved off the island to the Shoppes at Fiddler's Creek during the first half of the year.

The biggest loss is Marco Movies. The dine-in cinema on South Collier Boulevard in Marco Walk announced in early April that it would close after 32 years. It closed at the end of April. The general manager said on April 7 that there was "no successor," though he left the door open. No later announcement about the space turned up in local coverage through early October. So this season, an island night out of dinner and a movie means a trip off the island. Unlike the restaurants above, the cinema had no partner, regular or neighbor stepping in to keep it going.

The One New Dining Room Is Still Ahead

Marco Island's only significant new restaurant is coming to Rose Marina, the family-owned marina at 951 Bald Eagle Drive that has operated since 1969. The plan calls for a 200-seat restaurant overlooking and partly overhanging Factory Bay, plus more parking and reconfigured docks. The restaurant itself is a permitted use under the marina's C-5 zoning. What it needed were the approvals around it.

Marco News reported that it took two years, nine hours of planning board meetings and seven and a half hours of City Council time. The Planning Board voted 5-2 in July. Council finished three approvals at 12:55 a.m. on September 11, by 4-2 votes: a garbage and landscaping variance, a conditional use permit for boat storage, and a dock reconfiguration variance. Chairman Darrin Palumbo, Vice Chairman Rene Champagne and councilors Deb Henry and Kevin Dohm voted yes. Tamara Goehler and Stephen Gray voted no. Bonita Shwan attended online and could not vote, because state law requires in-person participation in quasi-judicial hearings.

Much of the debate wasn't about the restaurant. Most public comment was about the passenger ships that already dock at the marina. One resident at the meeting put it this way:

"They can build a restaurant; I don't care about that. When they bring the huge ship, before we know it, we're going to have trolley carts like Key West on Marco Island."

Goehler, who voted no, told the owners, "I will visit your restaurant." The site plan includes conditions: no more than three buses at a time, a 150-person cap on bus passengers, and no overnight stays by debarking vessels except in severe weather.

The approval will be felt on the water before any plates come out of a kitchen. The Key West Express announced in August that it would not bring its boat to Rose Marina this winter because of the "anticipated dock and parking improvements." It said it hopes to resume normal operations there as soon as possible.

The island's largest resort is going through its own change of ownership. In May, Sculptor Real Estate Income Strategy and Trinity Investments closed their $835 million purchase of the JW Marriott from MassMutual. Marriott still operates it under the JW brand. The buyers said renovations to guest rooms, the spa, the pools and the golf courses would happen mostly in their second year of ownership. As with the restaurants, the name on the building stays the same and any visible changes are scheduled for later.

The Calendar Holds Steady

While owners change, the season calendar looks familiar. Here are the dates already posted for this fall and winter:

  1. Musical Interludes at Marco Island Center for the Arts: Everton Azevedo on October 22, Leslie Cartaya on November 12 and Martin & Kelly on December 2, all at 5:30 p.m.
  2. "Life Beneath the Ruins" at the Art Center runs October 5 through November 24, with receptions October 13 and November 10. A "Day of the Dead" courtyard installation runs October 12 through November 13.
  3. Marco Island Art in the Park at Veteran's Park, October 17–18 from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., returning December 5–6.
  4. City beach cleanup at 8 a.m. on October 18, and the Halloween Spooktacular at Mackle Park at 4 p.m. on October 24.
  5. Marco Island Farmers Market at 901 Park Ave. opens November 18 and runs through April 14, 2027.
  6. Festival of Trees at the Art Center, December 1–3, followed by "Mud and Mistletoe" from December 7 through January 5, 2027.

The Farmers Market sets up at 901 Park Ave., which puts its Wednesday crowds a short walk from the Italian Deli at 902 Park Ave. and its new owners.

Whether you're thinking about a Factory Bay view from a future table at Rose Marina or just keeping up with who now runs your Friday night spot, Susan Barreiro follows these Marco Island changes closely and is happy to talk them over. When you'd like a local read on what's changing near your part of the island, let's connect.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Susan

Susan provides personalized service with integrity from beginning to end. She has a customer service focus and committed to the code of ethics.

Follow Me on Instagram